At a glance
- Each agreement sets a rate locked to the municipality's average usage over the previous 12 to 24 months.
- For infrastructure allocators, the asset is a municipal bill-savings contract, not a power purchase agreement, and the diligence item is the measurement baseline.
- Energy-as-a-service contracts are established at institutions such as universities and hospitals, said Eric Smith, professor of practice and associate director of the Tulane Energy Institute at Tulane University.
Budderfly plans to invest $500 million in energy upgrades for local governments and recover the investment from utility-bill savings over 15-year contracts, Utility Dive reported on Nov. 20.
Each agreement sets a rate locked to the municipality's average usage over the previous 12 to 24 months. Budderfly becomes the utility's customer of record and pays the municipality's bill, keeping a share of the savings from upgraded equipment. Savings above a 30% target are split 50/50 with the municipality, according to Budderfly's Edwards.
For infrastructure allocators, the asset is a municipal bill-savings contract, not a power purchase agreement, and the diligence item is the measurement baseline. The municipality pays a rate locked to its usage history while Budderfly pays the actual bill. Edwards said governments have access to lower-cost financing options and cited budget and staffing constraints.
Energy-as-a-service contracts are established at institutions such as universities and hospitals, said Eric Smith, professor of practice and associate director of the Tulane Energy Institute at Tulane University. Tulane's 2022 agreement with Enfra had the company pay for new energy assets, including a 1-MW solar facility, while the school received guaranteed annual savings over a 30-year term. Smith said on-site power also lets the campus island itself during hurricane-driven outages. "The way you get paid for that is to demonstrate that you're saving the ratepayer money," he said.
Budderfly has run the model once, investing $4.4 million in upgrades in Cadillac, Michigan, and will use Schneider Electric's energy management and automation technology to integrate and manage the systems. At Cadillac's scale, $500 million would cover roughly 110 municipalities.
"There's very little appetite anywhere to increase taxes to pay for energy infrastructure," Edwards said. Contracts that include virtual power plant programs and demand-side management give Budderfly and the municipality a route to share additional revenue alongside the savings, Edwards said.
Two energy-as-a-service deals, two contract designs
Contract terms: Budderfly's municipal offer versus Tulane's 2022 Enfra agreement
Budderfly / municipalities
$500 million plan
- Term
- 15 years
- Rate baseline
- 12-24 months of usage
- Savings target
- 30%
- Above target
- Split 50/50
Enfra / Tulane
1-MW solar, 30 years
- Announced
- 2022
- Savings
- Guaranteed annually
- Resilience
- Campus can island itself
Show as table
| Budderfly / municipalities | Enfra / Tulane | |
|---|---|---|
| Figure | $500 million plan | 1-MW solar, 30 years |
| Term | 15 years | |
| Rate baseline | 12-24 months of usage | |
| Savings target | 30% | |
| Above target | Split 50/50 | |
| Announced | 2022 | |
| Savings | Guaranteed annually | |
| Resilience | Campus can island itself |
The way you get paid for that is to demonstrate that you're saving the ratepayer money.Eric Smith, professor of practice and associate director of the Tulane Energy Institute at Tulane University
Reported by the Energy Transition desk from Utility Dive. Published . Corrections