Skip to content
Monday, November 2, 2026 · Today’s edition, 6:30 a.m. ETMon, Nov 2 · 6:30 a.m. editionSign inMy Desk 0EditionsSign in

Vanguard finds auto portability cuts small 401(k) cash-outs to 9%

The median transferred balance is $200, but an account needs about $800 to cover a year of fees at the $2 monthly fee Vanguard assumed.

9%Cash-out rate for departing balances under $1,000

At a glance

  1. The network moves a worker's small balance into the plan at a new employer.
  2. For balances between $1,000 and $7,000, the cash-out rate fell from 39% to 31%.
  3. For plan sponsors, the default's effect is concentrated in the smallest balances: the sub-$1,000 cash-out rate fell about 41 percentage points, while the $1,000-to-$7,000 change was smaller and driven more by participant choice.

Auto portability cut cash-outs among departing participants with less than $1,000 to about 9% from about 50%, Vanguard found across the 83 plans it recordkeeps that joined the Portability Services Network. The network moves a worker's small balance into the plan at a new employer. InvestmentNews first reported the research.

For balances between $1,000 and $7,000, the cash-out rate fell from 39% to 31%. Vanguard's researchers said that group's outcomes appear shaped more by participant choice than by default mechanics.

For plan sponsors, the default's effect is concentrated in the smallest balances: the sub-$1,000 cash-out rate fell about 41 percentage points, while the $1,000-to-$7,000 change was smaller and driven more by participant choice. Unmatched balances remain in an automatic rollover IRA, where a $2 monthly fee and 3% yield mean a $200 median balance cannot cover a year of fees; an account needs about $800.

PensionBee's analysis of Employee Benefit Research Institute data shows 68% of automatic rollover IRAs were worth less after one year. The accounts were meant as a short stop, yet 87% were still open after a year and 52% after eight. Of accounts open eight years, 39.4% had lost value, and the share down more than 75% rose from 1.8% after one year to 6.1% by year eight. Accounts that began at $1,200 or less lost value 47.1% of the time by year eight, compared with 29% of accounts that started above $2,500.

The network covered more than 21,000 plans in early 2026, about 3% of U.S. 401(k) plans by Vanguard's estimate. Vanguard said it has moved roughly 220,000 participants; the typical user is 31, with about six months of job tenure and roughly $20,000 in annual earnings. Vanguard built the network with Fidelity, Alight and Retirement Clearinghouse; Empower joined in 2023.

About 73% of the balances Vanguard transferred were $1,000 or less, and the median rollover is $200. Only about 6% of the 220,000 participants have been matched to a new employer plan; 94% remain in interim safe harbor IRAs, so the reduction in cash-outs so far lands mostly in the accounts PensionBee measured.

Cash-outs fell 41 points on the smallest balances

Share of departing participants who cashed out, before vs. after joining the network (%)

  • Before
  • After
  • Under $1,00050% → 9%
  • $1,000-$7,00039% → 31%
Source: Vanguard, 83 recordkept plans in the Portability Services Network
Show as table
ItemBeforeAfterChange
Under $1,00050%9%−41%
$1,000-$7,00039%31%−8%

Reported by the Plans & Sponsors desk from InvestmentNews — Retirement. Published . Corrections

Related

Retirement

The default, not the annuity shelf, now decides retirement income

BlackRock is selling the glide path, Vanguard found the RMD already won the decumulation default, and carriers are buying shelf access to a channel the default bypasses.

Retirement

Empower survey finds 76% of US adults want step-by-step guidance

Empower's 2,005-adult study also found 54% were unaware of options for retirement savings left behind at a former employer.

Retirement

68% of automatic rollover IRAs lost value in a year

An EBRI and PensionBee whitepaper estimates up to 13 million accounts holding as much as $43 billion, with $100 opening fees and $5 monthly maintenance.

Retirement

ADP and PNC bundle payroll, HR and retirement in one portal

The Oct. 28 offering places ADP's AI-enabled payroll tools inside PNC's small-business banking platform, with live payroll support around the clock.

Retirement

One in eight workers with higher health premiums cut retirement saving

A LIMRA survey reported by 401(k) Specialist found about half of workers facing higher premiums changed a benefits decision, and 17% had premiums jump more than 10%.

Retirement Capital Dailyfrom Private Wealth Daily

Plan menus, in-plan income, rollovers and recordkeepers. Daily at 7:00 a.m. ET.

Free. Every morning. Unsubscribe from any edition in one click.

From other sections

Vanguard finds auto portability cuts small 401(k) cash-outs to 9%