At a glance
- The 210 modifications with at least a 1% paydown retired $2.0 billion of balance, typically 5.4% of the loan.
- For a fund buying CMBS or pricing rescue debt, the paydown rate determines the opening cash ask.
- Borrowers who paid down received the same typical 12-month extension as those who did not.
One in five CMBS loan modifications since 2022 came with a borrower paydown, and those borrowers were half as likely to be in trouble two years later, Trepp found.
The 210 modifications with at least a 1% paydown retired $2.0 billion of balance, typically 5.4% of the loan. They are among 966 modifications Trepp has counted since January 2022. One in ten paydowns topped 18%, and most cash came from the borrower: only 23 were funded by selling a property out of a portfolio loan.
For a fund buying CMBS or pricing rescue debt, the paydown rate determines the opening cash ask. Special servicers attached a paydown to 28% of their modifications, versus 10% for master servicers. Single-asset, single-borrower loans paid down 32% of the time, conduit loans 19%, and loans of $100 million or more 27%. The pattern means a cash request is more likely in a workout on large single-borrower collateral than in the conduit stack.
Borrowers who paid down received the same typical 12-month extension as those who did not. Paydowns accompanied 31% of extensions but only 2% of forbearance agreements. Trepp's reading is that the cash earns a borrower an extension at all, not improved terms on it.
CMBS modifications fell to 37% as foreclosures climbed, Private Real Estate Daily previously reported.
Payers started healthier and still outperformed
Of the loans that paid down, 21% were in special servicing, delinquent or liquidated 12 months later, versus 40% of loans that did not, Trepp found. At 24 months the split was 17% and 39%; 51% of payers had repaid in full versus 18% of non-payers. These rates include loans that never left special servicing, so they run higher than redefault rates, which count only loans that exited.
The payers were healthier going in, and Trepp says that does not account for the gap. Their typical DSCR was 1.69x versus 1.44x, and their LTV 54% versus 59%. They outperformed in every DSCR and LTV band, and with the same mix of DSCR and property type, 36% of non-payers were in trouble.
Payers were half as likely to be in trouble
Share of modified loans in trouble at 12 and 24 months, and repaid in full, %
- Paid down
- No paydown
Select a row for its counts and shares.
In trouble at 12 mo
- Paid down2123.6% of all paid down
- No paydown4041.2% of all no paydown
In trouble at 24 mo
- Paid down1719.1% of all paid down
- No paydown3940.2% of all no paydown
Repaid in full
- Paid down5157.3% of all paid down
- No paydown1818.6% of all no paydown
Show as table
| Group | Paid down | Paid down share | No paydown | No paydown share |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| In trouble at 12 mo | 21 | 23.6% | 40 | 41.2% |
| In trouble at 24 mo | 17 | 19.1% | 39 | 40.2% |
| Repaid in full | 51 | 57.3% | 18 | 18.6% |
Mixed use leads the paydown table at 31%
By property type, mixed use borrowers paid down in 31% of modifications, ahead of multifamily at 27% and office at 24%. Lodging followed at 15% and industrial at 12%.
A 2023 modification on a New York office loan extended it by about two years, with the borrower paying down $5 million and depositing more than $6 million into leasing and capital reserves.
Mixed use borrowers paid down most often
Share of modifications with a paydown of at least 1% of balance, by property type
- Mixed use31%
- Multifamily27%
- Office24%
- Lodging15%
- Industrial12%
Show as table
| Item | Value (%) |
|---|---|
| Mixed use | 31% |
| Multifamily | 27% |
| Office | 24% |
| Lodging | 15% |
| Industrial | 12% |
Reported by the Real estate debt desk from Trepp and Private Wealth Daily. Published . Corrections