At a glance
- Credits must never compensate for a lack of emissions reductions.
- The principles ask corporates to treat credits as complementary to cutting their own emissions, not a substitute for doing so, and to use only high-quality credits.
- For allocators setting or reviewing net-zero mandates, the accounting principle has the sharpest consequence: a portfolio company's offset purchases must be visible outside its reported emissions, with a documented path to retirement.
PGGM, Achmea and insurer a.s.r published three principles on how companies should use carbon credits, removals and storage. Credits must never compensate for a lack of emissions reductions. The three Dutch institutions see a role for removals, according to Net Zero Investor.
The principles ask corporates to treat credits as complementary to cutting their own emissions, not a substitute for doing so, and to use only high-quality credits. They also require offset purchases to be reported separately from emissions disclosures. Companies should state the purpose of each credit they buy, shift progressively toward removals with a rising degree of permanence, and provide traceability from purchase to final retirement. The principles are addressed to corporates rather than to the signatories' own portfolios.
For allocators setting or reviewing net-zero mandates, the accounting principle has the sharpest consequence: a portfolio company's offset purchases must be visible outside its reported emissions, with a documented path to retirement. That moves the diligence question from whether a company buys credits to which credits it buys, what it says they are for, and where they are retired.
“Direct emissions reductions remain non-negotiable. At the same time, we must invest today in the high-quality carbon removals that the world will need over the longer term,” said Jeroen Rijk, head of Total Portfolio Management at PGGM.
Shell and Microsoft lead carbon credit retirement
Shell retired the most carbon credits by volume in 2024, 14.5 million, according to Net Zero Investor. Shell scrapped its 2035 carbon intensity target and weakened its 2030 goal in March 2024. Its 2026 energy transition strategy abandoned the 2035 target again and watered down the 2030 goal further. The company continues to expand LNG production.
Microsoft bought 93% of all carbon removal credits in 2025, according to Bloomberg NEF. The company, which anchored Just Climate's $540 million natural climate solutions fund as Private Wealth Daily previously reported, also saw emissions grow 25% to 34 million tonnes as it expanded AI data centres.
Two firms dominate, on two different measures
Shell's credits retired in 2024 and Microsoft's share of removal credits in 2025; measures are not comparable
Shell
14.5M credits
- Credits retired, 2024
- 14.5M
- 2035 carbon intensity target
- Scrapped
- 2030 goal
- Weakened twice
- LNG production
- Expanding
Microsoft
93% of removals
- Share of removal credits, 2025
- 93%
- Emissions, 2025
- 34 Mt
- Emissions change, 2025
- +25%
- Just Climate fund anchored
- $540M
Show as table
| Shell | Microsoft | |
|---|---|---|
| Figure | 14.5M credits | 93% of removals |
| Credits retired, 2024 | 14.5M | |
| 2035 carbon intensity target | Scrapped | |
| 2030 goal | Weakened twice | |
| LNG production | Expanding | |
| Share of removal credits, 2025 | 93% | |
| Emissions, 2025 | 34 Mt | |
| Emissions change, 2025 | +25% | |
| Just Climate fund anchored | $540M |
Direct emissions reductions remain non-negotiable. At the same time, we must invest today in the high-quality carbon removals that the world will need over the longer term.Jeroen Rijk, head of Total Portfolio Management at PGGM
Reported by the Who's investing desk from Net Zero Investor, Bloomberg NEF (via Net Zero Investor) and Private Wealth Daily archive. Published . Corrections