At a glance
- The claims challenge AT&T's $8.05 billion pension risk transfer to Athene Annuity and Life Insurance Co. On Sept. 28, U.S. District Judge Nathaniel Gorton preliminarily ruled that the claims against AT&T should be dismissed, following Magistrate Judge Paul Levenson's Aug. 31 report and recommendation.
- For plan sponsors weighing a PRT in the 1st Circuit, the question headed to appellate review is participant standing, ahead of any ruling on the merits of the Athene transfer.
- The request rests on a five-to-four split among federal appellate courts on plaintiffs' standing to challenge PRT transactions.
The parties in Piercy et al. v. AT&T Inc. et al filed a joint request Nov. 18 for an immediate appeal of whether plan participants can pursue their pension risk transfer claims, according to PLANADVISER. They also asked the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts to enter partial final judgment for AT&T.
The claims challenge AT&T's $8.05 billion pension risk transfer to Athene Annuity and Life Insurance Co. On Sept. 28, U.S. District Judge Nathaniel Gorton preliminarily ruled that the claims against AT&T should be dismissed, following Magistrate Judge Paul Levenson's Aug. 31 report and recommendation. Levenson found the plaintiffs had not shown AT&T was involved in the May 2023 selection of Athene as the annuity provider. Gorton let claims proceed against the fiduciary adviser AT&T selected, then known as State Street Global Advisors Trust Co. and now State Street Corp.
For plan sponsors weighing a PRT in the 1st Circuit, the question headed to appellate review is participant standing, ahead of any ruling on the merits of the Athene transfer. The U.S. 1st Circuit Court of Appeals, which includes the District of Massachusetts, has not issued a controlling opinion on that question. Sponsors in that circuit have no appellate standard to test a transaction against. An appellate ruling would address that threshold issue for plan fiduciaries. The district court's September order did not decide whether the transfer itself was prudent.
The request rests on a five-to-four split among federal appellate courts on plaintiffs' standing to challenge PRT transactions. The memorandum argued the case warrants interlocutory review, citing Philip Morris Inc. v. Harshbarger for the proposition that the order presents "difficult and pivotal questions of law not settled by controlling authority." It added that an immediate appeal would "materially advance the ultimate termination" of the case regardless of which side prevailed.
On partial judgment, the parties argued that the Sept. 28 order dismissed all claims against AT&T, so entering judgment would let the plaintiffs appeal the ruling that AT&T had no fiduciary responsibility for selecting Athene. They said that issue is distinct from the factual merits still pending against SSGA Trust Co. and that no party would be prejudiced by partial final judgment.
The claims against SSGA Trust Co. remain before the district court and were not part of the request for partial judgment. The next step is Gorton's ruling on whether to certify the standing question for appeal and enter judgment for AT&T.
The case moved from Athene's selection to an appeal request
Dated milestones in Piercy v. AT&T, from the annuity provider's selection to the Nov. 18 filing
- May 2023AT&T selects Athene for $8.05B pension risk transfer (Completed)
- Aug. 31Magistrate recommends dismissing claims against AT&T (Completed)
- Sept. 28Judge preliminarily orders AT&T claims dismissed (Completed)
- Nov. 18Parties request immediate appeal and partial final judgment (Current stage)
Show as table
| Date | Event | Detail |
|---|---|---|
| May 2023 | AT&T selects Athene for $8.05B pension risk transfer | |
| Aug. 31 | Magistrate recommends dismissing claims against AT&T | |
| Sept. 28 | Judge preliminarily orders AT&T claims dismissed | |
| Nov. 18 | Parties request immediate appeal and partial final judgment |
Reported by the Policy & ERISA desk from PLANADVISER. Published . Corrections