At a glance
- The answer will determine whether rates and data-center costs are examined at all.
- Joe Reid, a McGuire Woods partner representing the joint petitioners, told the State Corporation Commission that the case is "simply not the one to litigate the cost of service" or "who's paying their fair share ... including the data centers."
- For allocators holding regulated utility equity or generation serving these loads, the scope decision fixes what the record will show before the commission rules.
Hearings on NextEra's proposed acquisition of Dominion opened with a fight over how far Virginia's Utility Transfers Act reaches. The answer will determine whether rates and data-center costs are examined at all. The merger, announced in May, would create the largest regulated electric utility in the world with a 130 GW large-load pipeline, according to Utility Dive.
Joe Reid, a McGuire Woods partner representing the joint petitioners, told the State Corporation Commission that the case is "simply not the one to litigate the cost of service" or "who's paying their fair share ... including the data centers." He called the transaction a "consequential combination" whose size does not change the statute's requirements.
For allocators holding regulated utility equity or generation serving these loads, the scope decision fixes what the record will show before the commission rules. A narrow reading keeps the case to service adequacy. The broader reading sought by clean energy groups and Virginia officials would put Dominion's rate design at issue, including the minimum demand charge that Google's attorney said economist Carolyn Berry will testify discourages data centers from exercising retail choice.
Nate Benforado, a senior attorney with the Southern Environmental Law Center, argued the statute is broader than the petitioners allow. "The analysis that the Utility Transfers Act requires is broad," he said. "Petitioners must prove that this transaction will not impair or jeopardize adequate service at just and reasonable rates … This is not simply a 'do no harm standard.'"
Will Reisinger, representing the Piedmont Environmental Council, pointed to statutory language requiring the commission to "be satisfied" that adequate service at just and reasonable rates will not be impaired or jeopardized. "That standard, satisfied, is subjective," he said. "This decision is 100% within your judgment, within your discretion."
Will Cleveland, the attorney representing Google, said the company plans to present testimony from energy economist Carolyn Berry on the minimum demand charge approved in Dominion's 2025 biennial rate case. Dominion "doesn't think this testimony is relevant to the case," Cleveland said, and Google disagrees.
Clean energy groups, local Virginia officials and leaders of the state's executive branch have raised concerns about the deal's potential impact on rates and data center development. Virginia localities are acting on the same set of questions: Loudoun County adopted a 12-month data center moratorium, as Private Wealth Daily previously reported.
Admission of Berry's testimony would be an early marker of how widely the commission reads its own statute.
Reported by the Fundraising desk from Utility Dive and Private Wealth Daily archive. Published . Corrections