At a glance
- The group argues that FINRA, a private corporation, is exercising government power without effective government supervision, which it says the Constitution forbids.
- FINRA charged Darvish, who had no prior disciplinary history, with trading too frequently in four customer accounts, according to NCLA.
- For brokers at member firms, NCLA's account describes consequences that begin before any hearing: NCLA says FINRA rules penalize firms that employ someone fighting the charges, leaving a broker effectively unemployable from the day a case is filed.
The New Civil Liberties Alliance filed a complaint in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York challenging FINRA's disciplinary case against New York broker Michael Darvish, and plans to ask the court for a preliminary injunction to stop the proceeding.
The group argues that FINRA, a private corporation, is exercising government power without effective government supervision, which it says the Constitution forbids.
FINRA charged Darvish, who had no prior disciplinary history, with trading too frequently in four customer accounts, according to NCLA. The complaint says the charges rest on FINRA's own rules and an SEC regulation. Two of those customers have died, which NCLA says leaves Darvish unable to ask for their testimony in his defense. FINRA will oversee the January 2027 hearing itself and seeks a fine and a lifetime industry bar, the group said.
For brokers at member firms, NCLA's account describes consequences that begin before any hearing: NCLA says FINRA rules penalize firms that employ someone fighting the charges, leaving a broker effectively unemployable from the day a case is filed. SEC review of a disciplinary outcome comes only after FINRA's appellate arm and often takes years, according to the complaint.
Darvish was working as a representative for a FINRA-registered firm based in Garden City, New York, when FINRA began investigating the firm and members of its staff, NCLA said.
What the complaint asks for
Reported by the Practice management desk from The Manila Times / GlobeNewswire. Published . Corrections