At a glance
- Judge Naomi Reice Buchwald found the two-year noncompete likely unenforceable and that Cetera failed to show irreparable harm.
- For advisers weighing a move, the order shows a two-year noncompete can be a weak shield when the departing book is small relative to the firm it leaves.
- Cetera sued Lee on Oct. 30 over a team that managed $510 million in combined assets, according to the complaint.
A federal judge on Monday denied Cetera Financial Group's bid for a temporary restraining order against Michele I. Lee, who left for &Partners on Oct. 2.
Judge Naomi Reice Buchwald found the two-year noncompete likely unenforceable and that Cetera failed to show irreparable harm. The departing book was a small share of Cetera's assets, the judge wrote in an order filed in U.S. District Court in New York.
For advisers weighing a move, the order shows a two-year noncompete can be a weak shield when the departing book is small relative to the firm it leaves. Lee attested that she would return all documents and abide by the nonsolicitation and confidentiality provisions of her employment agreement, leaving those restraints intact.
Cetera sued Lee on Oct. 30 over a team that managed $510 million in combined assets, according to the complaint. The suit alleges she breached her employment contracts when she launched Sapphire Compass Advisors with &Partners, and Cetera claims customers with $130 million in assets have already moved their accounts to Lee and her team. Lee, a 31-year industry veteran first registered with Sands Brothers & Co. in 1993, departed with broker Meryl L. Futey and support staff Sam DiGiovanni.
Buchwald noted five years had passed since Lee sold her practice. Lee sold Headquarters Advisory Group to Avantax in August 2021, when Avantax was owned by Blucora; Cetera later acquired Avantax's wealth business, according to the complaint. The judge wrote that the public interest favored 'the rights of individuals to select their investment advisor.'
In April, a Financial Industry Regulatory Authority arbitration panel ordered &Partners and broker David M. Labourdette to pay Wells Fargo $1.25 million in damages, AdvisorHub reported. Cetera, Wells Fargo and &Partners are all signatories to the Protocol of Broker Recruiting, AdvisorHub reported, and &Partners hired a 14-advisor team from Wells Fargo this month, as Private Wealth Daily previously reported.
Buchwald granted Cetera limited expedited discovery to develop the record for a possible preliminary injunction hearing.
Lee sold her practice five years before she left
Events in Lee's career and Cetera's suit, in the order reported
- 1993First registered with Sands Brothers & Co. (Completed)
- 2015Launched Headquarters Advisory (Completed)
- Aug 2021Sold Headquarters Advisory to Avantax (Completed)
- Oct 2Left Cetera for &Partners (Completed)
- Oct 30Cetera sued Lee over the move (Completed)
- MondayJudge denies restraining order (Current stage)
Show as table
| Date | Event | Detail |
|---|---|---|
| 1993 | First registered with Sands Brothers & Co. | |
| 2015 | Launched Headquarters Advisory | |
| Aug 2021 | Sold Headquarters Advisory to Avantax | |
| Oct 2 | Left Cetera for &Partners | |
| Oct 30 | Cetera sued Lee over the move | |
| Monday | Judge denies restraining order |
Reported by the Recruiting & transitions desk from AdvisorHub and Private Wealth Daily's Moves Wire. Published . Corrections