At a glance
- The index behind the Invesco fund keeps only the stocks with the strongest growth scores and drops the middle band where names score as both growth and value.
- For advisors, the label stops doing the work of describing the exposure: two funds both called large-cap growth can finish a year roughly 20 points apart.
- On the value side the spread among leading large-value ETFs ran to 11 percentage points this year, according to the column.
Invesco's S&P 500 Pure Growth ETF returned 24.3% this year while the iShares Russell 1000 Growth ETF gained about 4.6%. The roughly 20-percentage-point gap comes from how each index scores and weights stocks, according to InvestmentNews, citing Jason Zweig's Wall Street Journal column.
The index behind the Invesco fund keeps only the stocks with the strongest growth scores and drops the middle band where names score as both growth and value. What remains is weighted by growth score rather than size. A traditional style index such as the S&P 500 Growth holds every stock with growth characteristics, including those that also score as value, and weights by market capitalization, which makes it behave like a mildly tilted version of the market. The column's author ran U.S. equities at S&P Dow Jones Indices, including the pure-style family behind the Invesco fund. He argues that anyone reading the two methodologies should expect the pure version to move differently from the Russell 1000 Growth. Zweig's warning, as the column quotes it, is that "the finer you slice-and-dice the market, the more concentrated it becomes."
For advisors, the label stops doing the work of describing the exposure: two funds both called large-cap growth can finish a year roughly 20 points apart. A model that pairs a growth sleeve with a value sleeve assumes the two are complements. Whether they are depends on each fund's scoring cutoff and weighting rule, the difference between owning the market's biggest growth companies and its most growth-like ones.
On the value side the spread among leading large-value ETFs ran to 11 percentage points this year, according to the column. Some of it came from classification: Micron Technology and Sandisk, two chipmakers the column describes as riding the AI boom, counted as value under Russell's price-to-book arithmetic because factories and equipment inflate book value. FTSE Russell says the pair drove roughly a fifth of the Russell 1000 Value Index's return before the June reshuffle moved them to growth.
A definition can also be redrawn under a fund that keeps its name. In 2018 S&P Dow Jones Indices and MSCI rebuilt the sector map, an effort the author helped lead at S&P, and telecom, a handful of dividend payers at about 2% of the S&P 500, became a communication services sector holding Alphabet, Facebook, Netflix and Disney at roughly 10% of the market. A telecom fund bought for its dividend yield was suddenly a growth holding.
As Wealth Advisor Daily previously reported, RSP equal-weights 504 stocks while EQL equal-weights the 11 sectors, leaving the two equal-weight funds with sector tilts that differ by design.
The rarer case the column flags is a prospectus that swaps one benchmark for another while the fund's name stays put, a change that would not show up in the label a client sees.
Two large-growth funds finished 20 points apart
Total return this year: Invesco S&P 500 Pure Growth vs iShares Russell 1000 Growth
Invesco Pure Growth
24.3%
iShares Russell 1000 Growth
4.6%
Same "large-cap growth" label; the gap comes from how each index screens and weights stocks.
Reported by the Products & portfolios desk from InvestmentNews, The Wall Street Journal, Jason Zweig column (as cited by InvestmentNews), Private Wealth Daily's Moves Wire and Wealth Advisor Daily archive. Published . Corrections