At a glance
- Higher rates and construction costs pushed Flatiron's underwriting toward bigger reserves and cost-based sizing, Ostad said.
- The reserve covers carry through an extended sale period and is written into the loan at origination.
- For allocators weighing private real estate debt, the number to test is the reserve: how many months of carry a loan pre-funds, and whether the contingency is cash a borrower can actually draw.
Private lender Flatiron Realty Capital has lengthened the interest reserve built into its bridge loans and sizes them against construction cost rather than projected value, founding partner Michael Ostad said in a Nov. 17 Partner Insights Q&A published by Commercial Observer.
Higher rates and construction costs pushed Flatiron's underwriting toward bigger reserves and cost-based sizing, Ostad said. "We size loans to what a project can afford if it takes longer to sell, not in the best case scenario," he said.
The reserve covers carry through an extended sale period and is written into the loan at origination. Leverage stays low, and the contingency must be money a borrower can actually draw.
For allocators weighing private real estate debt, the number to test is the reserve: how many months of carry a loan pre-funds, and whether the contingency is cash a borrower can actually draw. Because Flatiron sizes against cost rather than projected value, its loan-to-value is not directly comparable with a book sized on appraised value. The denominator differs even at the same leverage discipline.
Banks have pulled back from speculative construction, especially at the high end, he said. Builders who can still close have fewer places to go, and certainty of close matters more than the last quarter point on rate.
The split between receptive and difficult markets runs through the end buyer, Ostad said. In non-luxury single-family, the buyer needs a mortgage, and at 7% many cannot qualify, so builders sit on finished inventory, cut prices or buy down rates. In luxury, the buyer often pays cash and the rate barely touches the exit. Timing rather than saleability becomes the lender's risk, he said.
Flatiron concentrates on supply-constrained markets: Palm Beach, Miami, the Hamptons and Aspen, Colorado. Land is scarce there, zoning and approvals are slow and strict, and entry-level markets can add supply quickly, Ostad said.
Ostad cited national housing inventory of 1.6 million homes in September, the most since 2019, and about 43% of sellers cutting prices. He said that is evidence non-luxury supply keeps arriving, particularly in the Sun Belt.
Non-luxury supply keeps arriving
US homes for sale in September, the most since 2019; share of sellers cutting prices; mortgage rate Ostad cites
We size loans to what a project can afford if it takes longer to sell, not in the best case scenario.Michael Ostad, founding partner of Flatiron Realty Capital
Reported by the Real estate debt desk from Commercial Observer. Published . Corrections