At a glance
- In a Commercial Observer profile published Nov. 17, he said the situations are comparable in some ways and not in others.
- The bank, then New York Community Bank, reported a $2.7 billion loss in the fourth quarter of 2023, according to Commercial Observer.
- For a fund pricing a Flagstar real estate loan purchase or supplying rescue capital, the benchmark is a $552 million reserve build in one quarter and a $1 billion capital repair.
Scott Shepherd, tapped to stabilize Flagstar Bank's commercial real estate lending book, compares the task to the IndyMac turnaround he worked on under Steven Mnuchin in 2009. In a Commercial Observer profile published Nov. 17, he said the situations are comparable in some ways and not in others.
The bank, then New York Community Bank, reported a $2.7 billion loss in the fourth quarter of 2023, according to Commercial Observer. It set aside $552 million in loan-loss reserves tied to commercial real estate. Multifamily delinquencies rose 767% in the second quarter of 2024. Charge-offs climbed 590%. Chief executive Thomas Cangemi stepped down as the stock fell. In March 2024, a group led by Mnuchin injected $1 billion and installed Joseph Otting as chief executive. By October 2024, the bank had been renamed Flagstar Financial and changed its ticker to FLG.
For a fund pricing a Flagstar real estate loan purchase or supplying rescue capital, the benchmark is a $552 million reserve build in one quarter and a $1 billion capital repair. The March 2024 Mnuchin-led injection suggests the workout ran through Flagstar's own capital rather than bulk loan sales, which would mean fewer discounted Flagstar loans for sale.
The CRE problem followed two acquisitions. NYCB bought Flagstar in 2022 for $2.6 billion in stock, aiming to turn a multifamily originator into a full-service commercial bank. When Signature Bank failed in March 2023, Flagstar acquired $38.4 billion of Signature's assets and all of its deposits. The two deals pushed total assets above $100 billion, triggering higher capital, liquidity and reporting requirements.
Mnuchin bought failed residential lender IndyMac from the FDIC in 2009 for $13.9 billion, hiring Otting as president and Shepherd as head of commercial real estate banking. The parallel he draws is concentration: both banks were overloaded in one product type, according to the profile.
Even as it works through the legacy book, Flagstar is still committing capital to real estate funds. In September, Fifth Third joined Truist and Flagstar in CIM Group and BGV's affordable housing equity fund, as Private Wealth Daily previously reported.
From a $2.6B deal to a $1B rescue in two years
Dated events in the Flagstar workout, 2022-Oct. 2024
- 2022NYCB buys Flagstar for $2.6B in stock (Completed)
- Mar 2023Signature fails; Flagstar takes $38.4B of assets (Completed)
- Q4 2023$2.7B quarterly loss; reserves reach $552M (Completed)
- Mar 2024Mnuchin-led group injects $1B; Otting named CEO (Completed)
- Q2 2024Delinquencies up 767%; charge-offs up 590% (Completed)
- Oct 2024Renamed Flagstar Financial; ticker becomes FLG (Completed)
Show as table
| Date | Event | Detail |
|---|---|---|
| 2022 | NYCB buys Flagstar for $2.6B in stock | |
| Mar 2023 | Signature fails; Flagstar takes $38.4B of assets | |
| Q4 2023 | $2.7B quarterly loss; reserves reach $552M | |
| Mar 2024 | Mnuchin-led group injects $1B; Otting named CEO | |
| Q2 2024 | Delinquencies up 767%; charge-offs up 590% | |
| Oct 2024 | Renamed Flagstar Financial; ticker becomes FLG |
Reported by the Real estate debt desk from Commercial Observer and Private Wealth Daily archive. Published . Corrections