Skip to content
Tuesday, November 17, 2026 · Today’s edition, 6:30 a.m. ETTue, Nov 17 · 6:30 a.m. editionSign inMy Desk 0EditionsSign in

ERISA tobacco surcharge suits near 90 as law remains unsettled

The open question is whether employers must retroactively reimburse tobacco surcharges when employees complete cessation programs.

At a glance

  1. The reimbursement law is unsettled, Wheatley said in a Pensions & Investments article.
  2. Advisors who review wellness-program design for sponsor clients have no settled standard to test a tobacco surcharge against.
  3. Recent federal guidance limiting enforcement of certain retroactive reimbursement requirements may reassure plan sponsors, Wheatley said, but it “may not mitigate litigation risk.”

Roughly 90 ERISA lawsuits over tobacco surcharges in workplace wellness programs have been filed in recent years, according to Groom Law principal Kara Petteway Wheatley.

The reimbursement law is unsettled, Wheatley said in a Pensions & Investments article. The article examined whether employers must retroactively reimburse surcharges when employees complete smoking-cessation programs. Groom summarized her comments in a Benefits Brief published Nov. 16. “Right now, the law is unsettled,” Wheatley said.

Advisors who review wellness-program design for sponsor clients have no settled standard to test a tobacco surcharge against. The unresolved question is what a sponsor owes a participant who later completes a cessation program.

Recent federal guidance limiting enforcement of certain retroactive reimbursement requirements may reassure plan sponsors, Wheatley said, but it “may not mitigate litigation risk.”

Reported by the Policy & ERISA desk from Groom Law Benefits Brief and Pensions & Investments (via Groom Law summary). Published . Corrections

Related

Retirement

Form 5500 deadline stays July 31 as bill awaits passage

Groom attorneys say the proposed Form 5500 Filing Simplification Act would set an Oct. 15 deadline, but calendar-year plans still file by July 31.

Retirement

Plan advisers named in fee suits as 2026 filings near 120

Groom Law Group's Andrew Salek-Raham said about 600 suits have been filed in a decade and advisers can be named as defendants or witnesses.

Retirement

ERISA bill unlikely in lame duck, Groom Law's Winters says

Congress is facing budget and funding deadlines in the lame-duck session, leaving little room for retirement legislation.

Retirement

IRS finalizes SECURE 2.0 auto-enrollment rules for 2028 plan years

Covered plans default eligible employees at 3% and escalate at least 1 percentage point a year to 10%, starting with 2028 plan years.

Retirement

DOL proposes QPAM re-eligibility path after disqualification

A proposed class exemption would let asset managers win back eligibility through an independent fiduciary's certification rather than an individual EBSA exemption.

Retirement Capital Dailyfrom Private Wealth Daily

Plan menus, in-plan income, rollovers and recordkeepers. Daily at 7:00 a.m. ET.

Free. Every morning. Unsubscribe from any edition in one click.

From other sections