At a glance
- The plant had been set to retire in May 2025, and the cumulative extension now runs more than 20 months, according to the Environmental Defense Fund.
- The order came after a federal appeals court vacated a previous order for the same plant, ruling DOE had exceeded its authority.
- Consumers is seeking to recover "ballooning costs" from ratepayers in 11 states, EDF said: Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota and Wisconsin.
The Department of Energy ordered Consumers' 1,420-MW J.H. Campbell coal plant in Michigan to stay online another 90 days, until mid-February. The plant had been set to retire in May 2025, and the cumulative extension now runs more than 20 months, according to the Environmental Defense Fund.
The order came after a federal appeals court vacated a previous order for the same plant, ruling DOE had exceeded its authority. Environmental groups said they are "evaluating all legal options." Howard Learner, CEO of ELPC, called the latest purported emergency order "likewise illegal" and said "someone will be left holding the financial bag."
Consumers is seeking to recover "ballooning costs" from ratepayers in 11 states, EDF said: Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota and Wisconsin. That puts the dollar outcome of the extension in state cost-recovery proceedings across those jurisdictions, rather than in the wholesale power market where the plant's output is sold, which suggests the shareholders and customers exposed to each state's rate case carry different shares of the bill.
Consumers spent $303 million through the end of September to run the plant under the DOE orders after accounting for $344 million in market revenues, according to its quarterly filing. Utility Dive reported in June that Campbell was running at a 46.1% capacity factor, down from a nearly 66% average in the same periods over the previous four years.
According to DOE, coal plants across the U.S. "are being saved from premature retirement," and more than 17 GW of coal-fired generation was preserved in 2025.
Someone will be left holding the financial bag.Howard Learner, CEO of ELPC
Reported by the Energy Transition desk from Utility Dive. Published . Corrections