At a glance
- Morningstar's Center for Retirement & Policy Studies modeled four proposals in the report “From Access to Adequacy: Modeling Universal Automated Savings,” by Spencer Look and Jack VanDerhei.
- Sponsors that run voluntary enrollment today would carry a default, an opt-out process and a re-enrollment calendar that recordkeepers would administer.
- Automatic enrollment would become a requirement for existing 401(k) and 403(b) plans, extending SECURE 2.0's auto-enrollment rules for newly established plans.
Morningstar estimates that a package of automatic-savings policies could raise the share of Generation X, Millennial and Generation Z households projected to have enough retirement income to 67% from about 59%.
Morningstar's Center for Retirement & Policy Studies modeled four proposals in the report “From Access to Adequacy: Modeling Universal Automated Savings,” by Spencer Look and Jack VanDerhei. Adequacy is defined as income covering at least 100% of projected retirement expenses, using Morningstar's Model of U.S. Retirement Outcomes.
Sponsors that run voluntary enrollment today would carry a default, an opt-out process and a re-enrollment calendar that recordkeepers would administer.
Automatic enrollment would become a requirement for existing 401(k) and 403(b) plans, extending SECURE 2.0's auto-enrollment rules for newly established plans. Eligible workers who previously opted out would be re-enrolled every three years and could opt out again.
Largest gains among workers without a plan
A federally administered savings program would cover workers who lack an employer plan or a state-facilitated automatic IRA. Workers would be enrolled automatically in Roth-style accounts at 3% of pay, within existing IRA contribution limits, and could opt out.
Among households with no expected future years of retirement-plan participation under current conditions, Morningstar projects the share achieving retirement-income adequacy would rise to 48% from 37%. For Millennials in that group, the projected share rises to 51% from 32%. The 67% estimate covers the four proposals combined.
Proposals lift adequacy most for workers without a plan
Share of households projected to cover 100% of retirement expenses, current rules vs. four proposals combined (%)
- Current rules
- With proposals
- Gen X, Millennial, Gen Z59% → 67%
- No future plan participation37% → 48%
- Millennials without a plan32% → 51%
Show as table
| Item | Current rules | With proposals | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gen X, Millennial, Gen Z | 59% | 67% | +8% |
| No future plan participation | 37% | 48% | +11% |
| Millennials without a plan | 32% | 51% | +19% |
Reported by the Plans & Sponsors desk from PLANADVISER. Published . Corrections