At a glance
- The 10-year Treasury stood at 5.15% on Nov. 13, 45 basis points below the 5.6% average apartment cap rate for the 12 months through September, according to MSCI Real Capital Analytics data cited by Connect CRE.
- The Fed raised its target range to 3.75% to 4.00% on Sept. 16, then held on Oct. 28.
- A sponsor buying at a 5.6% cap with debt priced off a 5.15% 10-year plus a spread ends up borrowing above the going-in yield, according to Connect CRE.
Apartment acquisitions now often carry debt priced above the building's yield. The 10-year Treasury stood at 5.15% on Nov. 13, 45 basis points below the 5.6% average apartment cap rate for the 12 months through September, according to MSCI Real Capital Analytics data cited by Connect CRE. A lender's spread can push the coupon above the cap rate.
The Fed raised its target range to 3.75% to 4.00% on Sept. 16, then held on Oct. 28. Two weeks after the September move the 10-year reached 5.31%, its highest since 2002, within about 30 basis points of the trailing cap rate before any spread. Hotter-than-expected October inflation data lifted yields again in mid-November. Five- and seven-year yields, used to price fixed-rate acquisition loans, are up roughly 110 to 125 basis points since January, according to Connect CRE.
A sponsor buying at a 5.6% cap with debt priced off a 5.15% 10-year plus a spread ends up borrowing above the going-in yield, according to Connect CRE. That leaves negative leverage from day one, though the severity depends on the lender's spread and other terms.
The five-year Treasury stood at 4.98% on Nov. 13 against overnight SOFR of 3.90%, a gap of roughly 108 basis points, according to Connect CRE. That gap lets floating-rate loans offer a lower initial coupon than fixed-rate debt in many cases, depending on the lender's spread and other terms.
How much negative leverage a deal can absorb is now the underwriting question, and the answer turns on the lender's spread, prepayment schedule and conversion terms rather than the benchmark alone. Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae offer floating-rate programs with terms of five to 10 years, and after a one-year lockout prepayment can be as low as a flat 1% premium, according to Connect CRE. Fannie Mae's structured ARM also allows conversion to a fixed rate after the lockout, according to Connect CRE. Those terms suit acquisitions with a defined renovation or stabilization period, when the sponsor intends to refinance or sell once the work shows up in operating performance.
The median September Fed projection implied another quarter-point increase before year-end, and the October inflation report reinforced that view. In the week ended Nov. 13, the two-year Treasury yield rose more than 35 basis points. Futures priced a December hike as a near certainty, with some bets on a half-point, Connect CRE reported. Almost all Fed officials expect further rate hikes, as Private Wealth Daily previously reported, with two policymakers saying more than 25 basis points could be warranted in December if inflation data disappoints. A quarter point passed through to SOFR would lift the coupon on an unhedged floating-rate loan by roughly the same amount, other terms unchanged.
Fixed-rate debt now prices at the cap rate; floating does not
Treasury and SOFR rates on Nov. 13 vs. average apartment cap rate, 12 months through September
Show as table
| Label | Value (%) |
|---|---|
| Overnight SOFR | 3.9% |
| 5-year Treasury | 4.98% |
| 10-year Treasury | 5.15% |
| Apartment cap rate | 5.6% |
Reported by the Real estate debt desk from Connect CRE, MSCI Real Capital Analytics (figures cited by Connect CRE) and Private Wealth Daily archive. Published . Corrections