At a glance
- The selloff was a real-yield story, Patla wrote.
- An insurer buying agency MBS at the end of September collected 14bp more spread than at the end of August, but the duration it took on was longer, because rising rates slowed expected prepayments and extended mortgage durations.
- Hedging-related selling compounded the move in yields, and the ICE BofA MOVE index of implied rate volatility jumped from 75 to 110.
Agency mortgage-backed securities lost 3.38% in September, trailing Treasuries by 0.96 percentage points as option-adjusted spread widened 14bp to +43bp, its widest level since the April 2025 tariff announcements, according to Tyler Patla of Pioneer Investments.
The selloff was a real-yield story, Patla wrote. Of the 53bp rise in the 10-year Treasury yield, 48bp came from the 10-year TIPS yield, which closed September at its highest level since 2008. August payrolls rose 162,000, above expectations, and core CPI gained 0.25%, which Patla said all but guaranteed a hike. The Federal Reserve raised its target range 25bp to 3.75%–4.00% at the Sept. 16 meeting with a unanimous vote, and 16 of 18 participants projected at least one more increase before year-end. Chair Warsh said the move merely “removed a dose of accommodation.”
An insurer buying agency MBS at the end of September collected 14bp more spread than at the end of August, but the duration it took on was longer, because rising rates slowed expected prepayments and extended mortgage durations. The selling came mostly from active extension hedgers — dealers, hedge funds and mortgage REITs — while asset managers bought across the curve, Patla wrote.
Hedging-related selling compounded the move in yields, and the ICE BofA MOVE index of implied rate volatility jumped from 75 to 110. Patla wrote that September's near-parallel bear move produced the widening the historical relationship between the curve and MBS would suggest, but at roughly four times the average magnitude. Higher coupons drove most of the underperformance.
Agency MBS also lagged investment-grade credit, where the Bloomberg US Corporate Index essentially matched the return on duration-matched Treasuries. The MBS index instead gave up 0.96 percentage points of excess return.
Patla's review also flags a pilot program, progressing over the past several months, that uses VantageScore 4.0 as an alternative to Classic FICO, the single credit score mortgage lenders have relied on for three decades. MBS investors have paid extra for pools of lower-scoring borrowers because those borrowers tend to refinance more slowly when rates fall, he wrote.
For a general account, the arithmetic runs straight through the spread: the 14bp is compensation for duration that extended as rates rose. Whether it is enough depends on how much of September's prepayment slowdown persists.
What the Fed priced and what MBS paid
Reported by the Insurer portfolios desk from Insurance AUM Journal. Published . Corrections