Skip to content
Tuesday, November 17, 2026 · Today’s edition, 6:30 a.m. ETTue, Nov 17 · 6:30 a.m. editionSign inMy Desk 0EditionsSign in

AARP: narrower payroll tax base shortened Social Security trust fund by 25 years

The payroll tax base is 7 percentage points of GDP narrower than in 1984, a gap AARP estimates at $10.8 trillion.

$10.8TAdditional payroll tax revenue the 1984 base would have produced

At a glance

  1. AARP estimates that holding the 1984 share would have generated $10.8 trillion in additional payroll tax revenue from 1984 through 2034, enough to pay full scheduled benefits through 2059, 25 years longer than the Social Security trustees now project.
  2. For advisors, the analysis changes what drives a client's Social Security projection: wages above the taxable maximum are not taxed, so the projected depletion date depends on the tax base, not the client's contribution history.
  3. Two shifts explain the narrower base, the report says.

The share of gross domestic product subject to Social Security payroll taxes fell to 34% in 2025 from 41% in 1984, according to an AARP Public Policy Institute report on the program's finances.

AARP estimates that holding the 1984 share would have generated $10.8 trillion in additional payroll tax revenue from 1984 through 2034, enough to pay full scheduled benefits through 2059, 25 years longer than the Social Security trustees now project. PLANADVISER reported the findings on Nov. 16.

For advisors, the analysis changes what drives a client's Social Security projection: wages above the taxable maximum are not taxed, so the projected depletion date depends on the tax base, not the client's contribution history.

Two shifts explain the narrower base, the report says. Rising business profits and investment income have moved a greater share of economic growth from workers to capital, and wage gains have concentrated at the top: from 1979 to 2019, inflation-adjusted wages and salaries rose 41% for workers at the 90th percentile, compared with 9% at the median and 7% at the 10th percentile. Growth in pass-through businesses, including sole proprietorships, partnerships, LLCs and S corporations, adds to the effect because owners can report income as business profit rather than wages.

The combined Old-Age and Survivors Insurance and Disability Insurance trust funds held $2.6 trillion at the end of 2025 and earned $69 billion in interest last year, down from $2.9 trillion in 2020.

As Retirement Capital Daily previously reported, Sen. Bernie Sanders, in line to chair the Senate Social Security subcommittee, has proposed taxing earnings above $184,500 to fund a $2,400-a-year benefit increase. AARP's estimate covers revenue from 1984 to 2034, so it measures the taxable base that went untaxed, not any current proposal.

Wages grew 41% at the top, 9% at the median

Inflation-adjusted growth in wages and salaries, 1979-2019, by earnings percentile

  • Highlighted
  • Others
10th percentile10th percentile: 7%
MedianMedian: 9%
90th percentile90th percentile: 41%
Source: AARP Public Policy Institute, via PLANADVISER
Show as table
LabelValue
10th percentile7%
Median9%
90th percentile (highlighted)41%

Reported by the Policy & ERISA desk from PLANADVISER and AARP Public Policy Institute. Published . Corrections

Related

Retirement

Vanguard proposes six SECURE 3.0 reforms, led by auto-enrollment

Advisors with plan clients face questions about how a federal payroll-deduction IRA would interact with 17 state programs.

Retirement

ERISA bill unlikely in lame duck, Groom Law's Winters says

Congress is facing budget and funding deadlines in the lame-duck session, leaving little room for retirement legislation.

Retirement

Trump signs ESOP valuation bill with good-faith defense for fiduciaries

Fiduciaries who rely in good faith on an independent appraisal under IRS Revenue Ruling 59-60 get a statutory defense; the House passed the Senate text 401-14 in September 2026.

Retirement

Form 5500 deadline stays July 31 as bill awaits passage

Groom attorneys say the proposed Form 5500 Filing Simplification Act would set an Oct. 15 deadline, but calendar-year plans still file by July 31.

Retirement

IRS finalizes SECURE 2.0 auto-enrollment rules for 2028 plan years

Covered plans default eligible employees at 3% and escalate at least 1 percentage point a year to 10%, starting with 2028 plan years.

Retirement Capital Dailyfrom Private Wealth Daily

Plan menus, in-plan income, rollovers and recordkeepers. Daily at 7:00 a.m. ET.

Free. Every morning. Unsubscribe from any edition in one click.

From other sections